JSE at Wiley-Blackwell


Accepted Articles

Early View

Current Issue


  Manuscript Submission

Online Submission

Instructions for Authors

Copyright Transfer Agreement

 About JSE

Aims & Scope

Editorial Board

Online Office

Sponsors & Publisher

 Partner Journals

Other Journals from IB-CAS


Plant Diversity and Resources

Journal of Systematics and Evolution

Volume 55 Issue 6, Pages 559C565.

Published Online: 7 June 2017

DOI: 10.1111/jse.12252

Full Text HTML
Full Text PDF
Print this page
Inflorescence characteristics as function-valued traits: Analysis of heritability and selection on architectural effects

Mason W. Kulbaba1,2, Ilona C. Clocher1, and Lawrence D. Harder1*

1Department of Biological Sciences, University of Calgary, Calgary, Alberta, T2N 1N4, Canada

2Department of Ecology, Evolution, and Behavior, University of Minnesota, St. Paul, MN 55108, USA

Keywords: architectural effects; functional data analysis; heritability; inflorescence display; selection


Production of multiple flowers in inflorescences allows the reproductive phenotypes of individual plants to include systematic among-flower variation, which could be adaptive. Systematic trait variation within inflorescences could arise from resource competition among flowers, or be a developmentally determined feature of flower position, regardless of resource dynamics. The latter, architectural effect typically manifests as continuous floral variation within inflorescences. For architectural effects to be adaptive, floral trait variation among individuals must covary with reproductive performance and be heritable. However, heritability and phenotypic selection on gradients of variation cannot be estimated readily with traditional statistical approaches. Instead, we advocate and illustrate the application of two functional data analysis techniques with observations of Delphinium glaucum (Ranunculaceae). To demonstrate the parameters-as-data approach we quantify heritability of variation in anthesis rate, as represented by the regression coefficient relating daily anthesis rate to inflorescence age. SNP-based estimates detected significant heritability (h2 = 0.245) for declining anthesis rate within inflorescences. Functional regression was used to assess phenotypic selection on anthesis rate and a floral trait (lower sepal length). The approach used spline curves that characterize within-inflorescence variation as functional predictors of a plant's fruit set. Selection on anthesis rate varied with inflorescence age and the duration of an individual's anthesis period. Lower sepal length experienced positive selection for basal and distal flowers, but negative selection for central flowers. These results illustrate the utility and power of functional-data analyses for studying architectural effects and specifically demonstrate that these effects are subject to natural selection and hence adaptive.


Copyright © 2017. The Editorial Office, Journal of Systematics and Evolution, Institute of Botany, CAS
No. 20 Nanxincun, Xiangshan, Beijing 100093, China
Tel.: +86 10 62836132; 62836572    Fax:+86 10 62836132
E-mail: jse@ibcas.ac.cn