J Syst Evol ›› 2017, Vol. 55 ›› Issue (2): 85-109.doi: 10.1111/jse.12233

• Review •     Next Articles

Relative benefits of amino-acid, codon, degeneracy, DNA, and purine-pyrimidine character coding for phylogenetic analyses of exons

Mark P. Simmons*   

  1. Department of Biology, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, CO 80523-1878, USA
  • Received:2016-09-30 Online:2016-11-14 Published:2017-03-08

Abstract: Both traditional as well as 10 more recent methods of coding characters from exons of protein-coding genes are reviewed. The more recent methods collectively blur the distinction between nucleotide and amino-acid coding and enable investigators to carefully quantify the effects of different sources of phylogenetic signal as well as their potential biases. Codon models, which explicitly model silent and replacement substitutions, are a major advance and are expected to be broadly useful for simultaneously inferring recent and ancient divergences, unlike amino-acid coding. Degeneracy coding, wherein ambiguity codes are used to eliminate silent substitutions at the individual-nucleotide level, has clear advantages over scoring amino-acid characters. Nucleotide, codon, and amino-acid models are now directly comparable with easy-to-use programs, and widely used phylogenetics programs can analyze partitioned supermatrices that incorporate all three types of model. Therefore, it should become standard practice to test among these alternative model types before conducting parametric phylogenetic analyses. An earlier study of 78 protein-coding genes from 360 green-plant plastid genomes is used as an empirical example with which to quantify the relative performance of alternative character-coding methods using five quantification measures. Codon models were selected as having the best fit to the data, yet were outperformed by nucleotide models for all five quantification measures. Third-codon positions were found to be an important source of phylogenetic signal and even outperformed analyses of first and second positions for some measures. Degeneracy coding generally performed at least as well as amino-acid coding and is an arguably more effective alternative.

Key words: character-state space, codon models, composite characters, phylogenetic signal, phylogenomics, plastomics, saturation, transcriptomics

[1] Wu-Qin Xu, Jocelyn Losh, Chuan Chen, Pan Li, Rui-Hong Wang, Yun-Peng Zhao, Ying-Xiong Qiu, Cheng-Xin Fu. Comparative genomics of figworts (Scrophularia, Scrophulariaceae), with implications for the evolution of Scrophularia and Lamiales . J Syst Evol, 2019, 57(1): 55-65.
[2] Jun Wen, AJ Harris, Yash Kalburgi, Ning Zhang, Yuan Xu, Wei Zheng, Stefanie M. Ickert-Bond, Gabriel Johnson, Elizabeth A. Zimmer. Chloroplast phylogenomics of the New World grape species (Vitis, Vitaceae) . J Syst Evol, 2018, 56(4): 297-308.
[3] Vicki A. Funk. Collections-based science in the 21st Century . J Syst Evol, 2018, 56(3): 175-193.
[4] Ling Fang, Frederik Leliaert, Zhen-Hua Zhang, David Penny, Bo-Jian Zhong. Evolution of the Chlorophyta: Insights from chloroplast phylogenomic analyses . J Syst Evol, 2017, 55(4): 322-332.
[5] Jun Wen, AJ Harris, Stefanie M. Ickert-Bond, Rebecca Dikow, Kenneth Wurdack, Elizabeth A. Zimmer. Developing integrative systematics in the informatics and genomic era, and calling for a global Biodiversity Cyberbank . J Syst Evol, 2017, 55(4): 308-321.
[6] Elizabeth A. Zimmer,Jun Wen. Using nuclear gene data for plant phylogenetics: Progress and prospects II. Next-gen approaches . J Syst Evol, 2015, 53(5): 371-379.
[7] Morgan R. Gostel, Kiera A. Coy, Andrea Weeks. Microfluidic PCR-based target enrichment: A case study in two rapid radiations of Commiphora (Burseraceae) from Madagascar . J Syst Evol, 2015, 53(5): 411-431.
[8] Zhe-Chen Qi, Yi Yu, Xiang Liu, Andrew Pais, Thomas Ranney, Ross Whetten, Qiu-Yun (Jenny) Xiang. Phylogenomics of polyploid Fothergilla (Hamamelidaceae) by RAD-tag based GBS—insights into species origin and effects of software pipelines . J Syst Evol, 2015, 53(5): 432-447.
[9] Jin-Mei Lu, Ning Zhang, Xin-Yu Du, Jun Wen, De-Zhu Li. Chloroplast phylogenomics resolves key relationships in ferns . J Syst Evol, 2015, 53(5): 448-457.
[10] Hong QIAN, Jian ZHANG. Using an updated time-calibrated family-level phylogeny of seed plants to test for non-random patterns of life forms across the phylogeny . J Syst Evol, 2014, 52(4): 423-430.
[11] Anna-Magdalena BARNISKE, Thomas BORSCH, Kai MÜLLER, Michael KRUG, Andreas WORBERG, Christoph NEINHUIS, Dietmar QUANDT. Phylogenetics of early branching eudicots: comparing phylogenetic signal across plastid introns, spacers, and genes . J Syst Evol, 2012, 50(2): 85-108.
[12] Lei GAO, Ying-Juan SU, Ting WANG. Plastid genome sequencing, comparative genomics and phylogenomics: Current status and prospects . J Syst Evol, 2010, 48(2): 77-93.
[13] Xin-Hui ZOU; Song GE*. Conflicting gene trees and phylogenomics . J Syst Evol, 2008, 46(6): 795-807.
[14] Tracy A. HEATH; Shannon M. HEDTKE; David M. HILLIS*. Taxon sampling and the accuracy of phylogenetic analyses . J Syst Evol, 2008, 46(3): 239-257.
[15] Henner BRINKMANN; Herve PHILIPPE. Animal phylogeny and large-scale sequencing: progress and pitfalls . J Syst Evol, 2008, 46(3): 274-286.
Full text



[1] Yin Guo,Yunquan Wang,Lei Chen,Xiangcheng Mi,Haibao Ren,Shengwen Chen,Jianhua Chen. Comparing tree seedling composition and distribution patterns under different sampling intensities in the 24 ha Gutianshan forest dynamics plot[J]. Biodiv Sci, 2016, 24(10): 1093 -1104 .
[2] Yang Chang-You. New Records of Genera of Spermatophyte from Xinjiang[J]. J Syst Evol, 1985, 23(1): 61 -63 .
[3] Josefina G. Campoy, Rubén Retuerto, Sergio R. Roiloa. Resource-sharing strategies in ecotypes of the invasive clonal plant Carpobrotus edulis: specialization for abundance or scarcity of resources[J]. J Plant Ecol, 2017, 10(4): 681 -691 .
[4] CUI Ke-Ming and HU Zheng-Hai. Advancement of Structural Botany in the Past Fifty Years in China[J]. J Integr Plant Biol, 2002, 44(9): 1043 -1067 .
[5] Baodang Liu. Taking advantage of the media to expand the influence of IUCN’s Green List of Protected Areas in China[J]. Biodiv Sci, 2015, 23(4): 449 -450 .
[6] ZHANG Xiao-Quan, Xu De-Ying. A Canopy Radiation Model for Even-aged Plantation II Application and Validation[J]. Chin J Plan Ecolo, 2002, 26(1): 83 -88 .
[7] MA Li-Hui, WU Pu-Te, and WANG You-Ke. Spatial pattern of root systems of dense jujube plantation with jujube age in the semiarid loess hilly region of China[J]. Chin J Plan Ecolo, 2012, 36(4): 292 -301 .
[8] Živa Fišer Pečnikar, Nataša Fujs, Robert Brus, Dalibor Ballian, Elena Buzan. Insights into the plastid diversity of Daphne blagayana Freyer (Thymelaeaceae)[J]. J Syst Evol, 2017, 55(5): 437 -445 .
[9] PAN Yu-De, Melillo J. M., Kicklighter D. W., XIAO Xiang-Ming, McGuire A. D.. Modeling Structural and Functional Responses of Terrestria Ecosystems in China to Changes in Climate and Atmospheric CO2[J]. Chin J Plan Ecolo, 2001, 25(2): 175 -189 .
[10] Zhi-Qiang LU, Bin TIAN, Bing-Bing LIU, Chen YANG, Jian-Quan LIU. Origin of Ostryopsis intermedia (Betulaceae) in the southeast Qinghai–Tibet Plateau through hybrid speciation[J]. J Syst Evol, 2014, 52(3): 250 -259 .